AC 1.1 Compare and contrast legal and equitable interests in land

LAW503: Land Law Assignment

Plagiarism and Collusion

In submitting the assignment, Learners must complete a statement of authenticity confirming that the work submitted for all tasks is their own. The statement should also include the word count.

Plagiarism and collusion are treated very seriously. Plagiarism involves presenting another author`s work, excerpts, ideas, or passages without appropriate referencing and attribution.

Collusion occurs when two or more learners submit work that is so alike in ideas, content, wording, and/or structure that the similarity goes beyond what might have been mere coincidence.

Referencing

A professional approach to work is expected from all learners. Learners must therefore identify and acknowledge ALL sources/methodologies/applications used.

The learner must use an appropriate referencing system to achieve this. Marks are not awarded for the use of English; however, the learner must express ideas clearly and ensure that appropriate terminology is used to convey accuracy in meaning.

Please use the Harvard Style of Referencing throughout your work.

Appendices

You may include appendices to support your work. However, appendices must only contain additional supporting information and must be clearly referenced in your assignment.

You may also include tables, graphs, diagrams, Gantt charts, and flowcharts that support the main report and should be incorporated into the back of the submitted assignment report

Any published secondary information such as annual reports and company literature should be referenced in the main text of the assignment, following Harvard Style Referencing, and referenced at the end of the assignment.

Confidentiality

When Learners choose to include organisational information that deals with sensitive material or issues, they must seek advice and permission from that organisation about its inclusion.

Where confidentiality is an issue, Learners are advised to anonymise their assignment report so that it cannot be attributed to that particular organisation.

Word Count Policy

Learners must comply with the required word count within a margin of +10%. These rules exclude the index, headings, tables, images, footnotes, appendices, and information within references and bibliographies.

When an assessment task requires learners to produce presentation slides with supporting notes, the word count only applies to the supporting notes.

Marking and Grades

The details of a standard marking rubric can be found at the end of this document. Unless stated elsewhere, learners must answer all questions in this document.

Submission of Assignments

Before submitting your work check you have:

✓ Completed the tasks or activities as required by the assignment

✓ Labelled or numbered each task or activity

✓ Understood and responded to the command verbs in the Assessment Criteria

✓ Produced the tasks or activities in the required format

✓ Presented your work clearly

✓ Referenced sources you have used and cited from

✓ Put cited material in quotation marks

✓ Checked for any spelling or grammatical errors

✓ Added a footer with page number

Assignment Question

Assignment - Total word count - 2,000 words

You are working for a law firm and have been asked to prepare notes on the following matters in relation to land law.

Task 1- 1000 words

Grace owns a pig farm in Lincolnshire which she has been running with her brother Graham. On Graham’s death in 2005, the ownership of the farm passed to her but she found it too much for her to manage alone. She speaks to her son Karl and asks him to move back home to help with the farm. Karl is working in Birmingham in an accountancy firm with prospects of partnership. Grace tells Karl that the farm will be his one day so it is in his interest to help keep it going. Karl gives up his £60,000 a year job and prospects of partnership and moves back to the farm. He lives rent-free in the farmhouse with Grace and works on the farm for a minimal salary. Karl also upgrades the farm over the next few years using his own savings as Grace tells him she has left it solely to him in her will.

In May 2019, Grace leased some of the farm`s land to Katia to run a riding school and has granted Katia permission to ride across the remaining farmland. Grace agrees to sell Katia the freehold of the land for £300,000. Katia wants to negotiate a lower purchase price but says she will buy the land as long as she can obtain planning permission for a house and new buildings for the riding school.

Grace dies in early June and in her will leaves the entire estate to the National Trust. Explain the nature of interests in real property and advise Karl and Katia whether they can enforce the arrangements made with Grace. In the case of Katia this would include the sale of land and continuing lease and licence rights that may exist.

Your notes should:

• Compare and contrast legal and equitable interests in land. (AC1.1)
• Differentiate between personal and proprietary interests. (AC1.2)
• Explain different types of licences and ownership. (AC1.3)
• Explain the meaning of proprietary estoppel. (AC2.1)
• Analyse the conditions for its creation. (AC2.2)
• Examine available remedies. (AC2.3)

Task 2 - 1000 words

Saskia is the registered freehold owner of a large estate which includes the Manor House, which is her home, Rose Cottage which she has been leasing to Naseem for the last three years and East field which is being occupied by Terrence who runs a fishing club. She used to also own West field which she sold some years ago to Tina who gained planning permission to build on the land and now lives there.

a) Rose Cottage is set in its own garden. There are no easements. Saskia gave Naseem permission to keep his motorbike outside the garden of the property on Manor House land that is not part of the lease. After an argument, Saskia told Naseem that he is no longer allowed to park his bike on the land.

b) East Field has been occupied and developed by Terrence as a fishing centre since 2005. He has improved the riverbank, planted hedgerows and trees and has recently erected a small wooden lodge which he runs as a café and fishing supplies shop. He has started charging for entry to the field. Saskia owns the land and the fishing rights. Terrence has occupied the land for some years at no inconvenience to Saskia and she has allowed this. Her son has encouraged her to evict Terrence from the land.

c) WestField was sold two years ago to Tina for her to build a house. As part of the sale, Saskia made and registered a covenant that allowed Tina to erect one, single-story property on the land and use it for residential purposes only. Saskia covenanted that she would keep the dry stone wall between the Manor House garden and West Field in good repair. Now Tina has decided to build a second storey on her house and an extension to open a tearoom to which Saskia objects. In addition, Saskia has allowed the wall to fall into disrepair. If she can’t build, Tina is considering selling the property.

You are required to consider:

• Naseem’s right to park on the land outside the cottage garden
• Terrence’s rights to remain on the land and Saskia’s rights in relation to the land.
• The rights that exist to enforce the covenant in place relating to the West Field building and the boundary wall now and in the event of Tina selling the property.

Your notes should:

• Explain the rules for the creation and acquisition of legal and equitable easements. (AC3.1)
• Distinguish between negative and positive easements. (AC3.2)
• Explain how easements are extinguished. (AC3.3)
• Distinguish between positive and restrictive covenants. (AC4.1)
• Explain how the benefit and burden run in law and in equity. (AC4.2)
• Explain how freehold covenants are discharged or modified. (AC4.3)
• Explain how adverse possession is established. (AC5.1)
• Illustrate registered owners’ protection against adverse possession under the LRA 2002. (AC5.2)
• Illustrate the advantages of registered proprietors in the context of adverse possession. (AC5.3)

Marking Rubric: